The
following issues will vary in importance to each landowner, often
dictated by the landowner's intended use of the property. The issues
raised are deviations from the companies' typical gas or oil contracts
but have all been accepted by the companies -- though probably not all
concessions are made in a single contract. This list is intended to
give the land owner options to consider. We do not guarantee that a
land owner will be able to negotiate each nor is it a fully
comprehensive list of issues. We do feel that legal advice should be
sought from an appropriate professional before signing any contract.
Factors Affecting Remuneration/Payments:
Companies
generally offer a 12.5% royalty. Owners of desirable properties and
landowners who have worked together have also been able to negotiate
higher royalties although we have not heard of any exceeding 12.5% in
our area
Royalty proceeds should be based on gross value, not net.
Landowners
own to the middle of the road but tax roles often do not include this
in their calculation of property size. Land owners with significant
road frontage should be sure the royalty is based on the correct
acreage owned.
The owner should be guaranteed timely access to
accounting/audit data to verify the calculation of royalties.
Signing
bonuses have been increasing dramatically in the Twin Tiers but the
greatest interest is the townships bordering the Pennsylvania border
where an infrastructure for transporting the gas is already in place.
The bonus being offered in Lindley, for example, moved from $50 per
acre in December 2007, to $200 per acre in April and June 2008, $350 an
acre in July and $1,000 an acre in October.
Contract
terms are usually for 5 years with the company having the right to
renew for another 5 years. Some residents have been offered 3 year
contracts with the right of renewal for another 3 year period. Others
have been offered a 5 year contract with no renewal
.
Considerations around Use of the Property
The landowner can increase the distance a well must be from any structures on the property.
The maximum size of a site and its maintenance should be specified in the contract.
The land owner should be consulted prior to the establishment of roads, wells, pipelines or other equipment. The landowner
may or may not negotiate a right of refusal.
The
NY State Department of Agriculture and Markets has
established recommendations for pipeline right-of-way construction
projects for agricultural areas. The landowner can require the gas
company to follow those regulations, even if the property is not
currently used for agriculture.
We strongly recommend against
use of the property for storing gas or oil. Storage is typically
established with no end-date and effectively eliminates the land owner
from future gas or oil exploration. If a certain proportion of
landowners agree to it, the gas company can petition the courts to
force others in the area to permit it.
Disposal of waste or pollution should be addressed in the contract.
The
contract should specify whether the land owner will have access to
roads and/or other improvements made by the gas company as well as an
understanding of who will pay increased property taxes resulting from
those improvements.
Use of Resources
The contract should specify whether resources such as water, gravel, timber, electricity, gas, oil, etc. will be
available to the gas company at no cost or for a fee.
What remuneration will be paid for the permanent or temporary loss of resources or damage to existing structures?
Is the lease for 1 formation or strata only (i.e., Marcellus, Utica, Trenton Black River gas deposits? Oil?)
Other Issues
Force Majeure:
This clause was developed to protect one party in the event they are
unable to meet the terms of a contract because of "Acts of God," war,
etc. It has been expanded in many contracts to exonerate the gas
company from its responsibilities for events that may be viewed as
controllable such as strikes, problems with suppliers, etc. We
recommend that land owners use the wording as originally developed.
Gas from Other Production Units: Some property owners have negotiated payments when gas produced in other production
units is conveyed through the pipelines on their property.
Contract Type:
It is important to understand the legal ramifications of contract terms
such as "conditions", "covenants", and "clauses". They can affect the
ease of the land owner's right to sue and determine whether or not
punitive damages can be awarded.
Warranties of Title:
In some cases, land owners in the 1800s signed away their mineral
rights ad infinitum. The typical gas company lease states that the
owner warrants title to these resources. We recommend that the land
owner strike that clause.
Contract Interpretation:
In recognition that the gas company has a greater understanding of the
implications of the legal contract, it should be specified that
ambiguous wording or other unclear provisions should be interpreted in
favor of the landowner. (Note that this does not
absolve the land owner from being informed. Definitions that have been
established by law will stand, even if the land owner claims not to
have understood the implication.)